Ever have one of those mornings where you’re torn between eating clean and just giving in to a sweet craving? That’s exactly how this cookies and cream protein shake became my go-to. I remember sitting at my kitchen table with a half-eaten cookie in one hand and a scoop of protein powder in the other, thinking—what if I just put them together? That’s how this creamy, dreamy shake was born.
Growing up, cookies and cream was always my favorite. Whether it was ice cream, candy bars, or snack cookies tucked into my lunchbox, I couldn’t resist. But now, I need something that fuels my day—something that tastes indulgent but still supports my goals. That’s where the cookies and cream protein shake shines. It brings comfort and nostalgia, but also delivers serious post-workout recovery or a satisfying midday snack.
This shake is thick, flavorful, and so easy to make, you’ll be sipping it before your blender even cools down. It’s sweet, satisfying, and protein-packed, making it perfect for busy mornings or post-gym recovery. And if you love cookies and cream flavors as much as I do, you’re going to love pairing it with options like a cookies and cream protein bar or my indulgent cookie butter cold brew.
So, if you’re craving something that tastes like dessert but works like fuel, this cookies and cream protein shake is just what you need.
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
For more Follow me on Facebook & Pinterest
What’s in a Cookies and Cream Protein Shake?
This delicious cookies and cream protein shake is made with simple, smart ingredients that deliver on both flavor and nutrition. Here’s a look at what makes this shake so satisfying and how you can customize it for your goals.
Main Ingredients Breakdown
To make the perfect cookies and cream protein shake, you’ll need:
- Cookies and cream protein powder – The main flavor base and your protein source.
- Milk or milk alternatives – Use dairy milk for creaminess or almond/oat milk for lighter options.
- Greek yogurt – Adds thickness and more protein.
- Vanilla extract – Enhances the dessert-like flavor.
- Crushed cookies – Mini Oreos or healthy cookie options.
- Ice – Optional, but helps with texture and chill.
Want to see how these ingredients compare?
| Ingredient | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Protein Powder | Main protein source and flavor |
| Milk / Alternative Milk | Creamy base |
| Greek Yogurt | Adds thickness and extra protein |
| Crushed Cookies | Gives it cookies and cream texture |
Best Cookies and Cream Protein Powders
To really nail this cookies and cream protein shake, pick a powder that tastes great and blends smoothly. Options like Ghost, Clean Simple Eats, or Premier Protein are all solid choices. If you’re asking, “Is the cookies and cream Premier Protein good?”—absolutely. It’s creamy, not too sweet, and works perfectly in shakes.
Want to amp up your shake? Try it with crushed pieces of a cookies and cream bar or even a spoon of nut butter. This cookies and cream protein shake is your canvas—make it yours.
Print
Cookies and Cream Protein Shake: The Creamy, Crave-Worthy Way to Boost Your Day
- Total Time: 5 min
- Yield: 1 shake 1x
Description
A rich, creamy cookies and cream protein shake that’s easy to make and packed with protein—perfect for breakfast, post-workout, or a healthy dessert.
Ingredients
1 scoop cookies and cream protein powder
¾ cup milk or milk alternative
½ cup Greek yogurt
½ tsp vanilla extract
2–3 crushed Oreo or sandwich cookies
4–5 ice cubes
Instructions
1. Add milk to blender.
2. Scoop in protein powder.
3. Add Greek yogurt and vanilla.
4. Toss in crushed cookies and ice.
5. Blend until smooth.
6. Serve immediately.
Notes
You can substitute the cookies for a cookies and cream protein bar.
For thicker texture, add frozen banana or oats.
- Prep Time: 5 min
- Cook Time: 0 min
- Category: Protein Shake
- Method: Blended
- Cuisine: American
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1
- Calories: 250
- Sugar: 6g
- Sodium: 180mg
- Fat: 7g
- Saturated Fat: 2.5g
- Unsaturated Fat: 3g
- Trans Fat: 0g
- Carbohydrates: 20g
- Fiber: 2g
- Protein: 24g
- Cholesterol: 20mg
Keywords: cookies and cream protein shake, high protein shake, post workout shake
How to Make a Creamy, Protein-Packed Shake
So you’ve got the ingredients lined up—now let’s make this cookies and cream protein shake the right way. What I love most is how flexible the recipe is. You can make it thick and spoonable, or light and sippable, depending on your mood or your macros. With the right steps and small tweaks, you’ll be drinking something that feels like dessert but works like fuel.
Easy Blending Steps
Making a cookies and cream protein shake is truly as easy as blend and go. Here’s my go-to method:
- Start by adding your liquid base—about ¾ cup of milk or your preferred dairy-free alternative.
- Add 1 scoop of your favorite cookies and cream protein powder.
- Spoon in ¼ to ½ cup of Greek yogurt for creaminess and added protein.
- Toss in 4–5 ice cubes for texture and chill.
- Sprinkle in 2–3 crushed cookies (Oreo Thins work well for balance).
- Add ½ teaspoon of vanilla extract.
- Blend until smooth and creamy—usually 30 seconds on high.
If you’re feeling adventurous, you can also toss in half a banana or a tablespoon of peanut butter. The banana adds natural sweetness, while peanut butter pairs amazingly with cookies and cream. For a fun twist, check out my peanut butter banana cookies—the flavor combo works beautifully in a shake too.
This simple method results in a thick, rich shake that satisfies your craving for something sweet while delivering on protein and energy.
Make It Thicker or Thinner
Everyone likes their cookies and cream protein shake a little different. Want it ultra-thick, like a smoothie bowl? Add more Greek yogurt, frozen banana, or a few oats. Want something thinner and easier to sip through a straw? Just reduce the yogurt and go with more liquid.
Here’s a cheat sheet to guide your texture goals:
| Texture | What to Add |
|---|---|
| Thicker | More Greek yogurt, frozen banana, oats |
| Thinner | Extra milk, less yogurt, skip the ice |
And yes—you can absolutely put Oreos in a protein shake. In fact, they’re what give this shake its signature “cookies and cream” bite. For more portion-conscious or low-sugar options, try using a crumbled piece of your cookies and cream bar or even protein cookie crumbles.
If you’re looking to enjoy this shake as part of a sweet snack combo, it also pairs beautifully with small batch chocolate chip cookies. You get the comfort of cookies, the benefit of protein, and all the nostalgic flavor you love—without the guilt.
Shake Variations and What Goes Well With It
One of the best things about a cookies and cream protein shake is how flexible it is. You can go classic, keep it clean, or get creative with new flavors and textures. Once you’ve nailed the base recipe, the variations are endless—and so much fun to try.
Creative Flavor Twists
Sometimes you want something a little extra. A tiny tweak to your cookies and cream protein shake can totally change the experience. Add a splash of peppermint extract for a cool, minty vibe. Try blending in a tablespoon of nut butter for richness—or even a few dark chocolate chips if your macros allow.
You can also swap out ingredients to match seasonal flavors. For example, mixing in cinnamon and vanilla almond milk gives your shake a cozy fall twist. Or, blend in frozen strawberries and white chocolate chips for a berries-and-cream version.
If you’re already experimenting in the kitchen, you’ll enjoy trying this shake alongside these cookie creations:
- The white chocolate chip cookies bring a buttery-sweet contrast.
- The double chunk chocolate cookie offers bold richness to complement the shake’s creamy texture.
Think of this shake as a dessert-style protein base you can play with.
Pairing with Snacks or Meals
Let’s answer a key question: what goes well with cookies and cream? The answer goes beyond just cookies. This shake pairs beautifully with a balanced snack plate—think banana slices, a few almonds, or a rice cake with peanut butter. The blend of sweet, crunchy, and creamy keeps your energy stable without overloading on sugar.
Looking for a full post-workout combo? Try this shake with:
- Peanut butter cookies: adds protein and a salty-sweet balance
- Chocolate chip cookie cake: makes it feel like a true treat day
These combinations bring flavor and function together. Whether you enjoy it as breakfast, dessert, or a post-gym refresher, this cookies and cream protein shake works in all kinds of moments.
And for a lighter option, pair it with vegan chocolate chip cookies for a plant-powered snack you can feel good about.
What goes well with cookies and cream?
Cookies and cream pairs well with all kinds of flavors—especially peanut butter, chocolate, vanilla, banana, and coffee. A spoonful of nut butter or a side of peanut butter oatmeal cookies makes this shake even more satisfying. You can also enjoy it with a light snack like a rice cake or even cold brew for an energizing twist.
What’s in a cookies and cream milkshake?
Traditionally, a cookies and cream milkshake includes vanilla ice cream, milk, and crushed Oreo-style cookies. But in a protein shake version, you get the same creamy texture with better ingredients: protein powder, Greek yogurt, milk or milk alternatives, crushed cookies, and ice. It tastes indulgent, but it’s much more balanced.
Can you put Oreos in a protein shake?
Yes, you absolutely can. Oreos or mini sandwich cookies add that signature cookie crunch. For a healthier twist, use Oreo Thins or crumble in a homemade cookie like these 4-ingredient peanut butter cookies. You can also skip traditional cookies and use a high-protein cookies and cream bar instead.
Is the cookies and cream Premier Protein good?
Premier Protein’s cookies and cream flavor is one of their most popular—and for good reason. It’s creamy, smooth, and not overly sweet. It blends well into shakes or can be sipped on its own. If you’re short on time or want a grab-and-go option, it’s a great pick.
Conclusion: A Shake That Hits the Sweet Spot
The cookies and cream protein shake isn’t just a healthier way to satisfy your cravings—it’s a fast, flexible recipe that fits into your life. Whether you’re fueling up post-workout or replacing a sugary snack, this shake delivers on flavor and function. It’s creamy, comforting, and totally customizable.
From nostalgic cookie flavor to modern nutrition, this shake bridges the gap between dessert and daily wellness. And if you loved this recipe, don’t miss out on trying our chocolate cookies recipe or the surprisingly satisfying keto peanut butter cookies—perfect partners for your next shake break.
So grab your blender, your favorite cookie crumbles, and enjoy every sip. Because healthy should still taste like something you love.