Ice cream cookies are the ultimate dessert mashup—chewy, melty, and full of surprise flavor in every bite. This recipe goes beyond the basics by blending your favorite ice cream right into the cookie dough, creating an ultra-soft texture and a fun twist on the classic chocolate chip cookie. Whether you’re using mint chip, cookie dough, or seasonal favorites, these cookies are endlessly customizable and always a crowd-pleaser. In this article, we’ll explore how to make them perfectly, why they work, and how to take them to the next level with smart pairings and easy tips. Let’s get baking!
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
For more follow me on Facebook & Pinterest
Ice Cream Cookies: A Sweet Fusion of Flavor and Fun
From Freezer Surprise to Cookie Perfection
Ice cream cookies weren’t something I planned—they were a happy accident born from a freezer full of half-used cartons and a craving for something different. I had my favorite chocolate chip cookie dough recipe ready to go, but that day, the butter was low and my curiosity was high. So I reached for the ice cream. I figured: why not replace part of the butter and egg with a scoop of full-fat vanilla? One batch later, I was hooked.
The result? Pure joy. Those ice cream cookies had the familiar comfort of warm chocolate chip dough but with creamy richness and subtle flavor twists. Every bite held a bit of that frozen surprise—mint chip brought cool freshness, strawberry added a soft sweetness, and cookie dough made them feel extra indulgent.
And the best part? You can use almost any ice cream flavor. Want Cookie Monster ice cream? That bright blue scoop packed with Oreo and chocolate chip bits makes these cookies pop at parties. Or if you love chocolate overload, go for chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream to double the fun. The key is choosing full-fat ice cream to get the best result.
These aren’t just cookies—they’re ice cream cookies with personality. If you enjoy fun combos, try making a chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich next.
Why This Recipe Works (and Always Will)
The magic behind ice cream cookies lies in balance. Ice cream contains many of the same ingredients as traditional cookie dough—cream, eggs, and sugar—so it blends beautifully. Replacing some butter and egg with your favorite flavor adds moisture and richness, creating cookies with golden edges and perfectly soft centers.
Each batch offers a custom flavor story. Vanilla creates a classic richness, strawberry gives a fruity finish, and cookies and cream tastes like dessert layered on dessert. They even work great with seasonal scoops like Blue Bell’s Christmas Cookie flavor, usually available in the freezer aisle during holidays.
Want to go beyond the basics? Pair them with a slice of cookies and cream ice cream cake or turn leftover scoops into an exciting treat instead of letting them collect freezer frost.
These ice cream cookies are all about joy, creativity, and chewy-centered goodness. And if you’re curious about variations, check out cookie and cream cookies or test out a lighter option like sugar-free cookie dough.
Creative Ways to Customize Ice Cream Cookies
Best Ice Cream Flavors to Use in Cookies
One of the reasons ice cream cookies are so fun to make is that no two batches ever have to be the same. Your choice of ice cream completely changes the final cookie—from the flavor to the texture to the aroma in your kitchen. Here are some favorites that always work well:
- Vanilla bean: Classic, creamy, and neutral. It highlights the chocolate chips beautifully and adds a smooth background.
- Mint chip: Adds a cool and refreshing note. Pairs great with dark chocolate chips.
- Strawberry: Brings a soft fruitiness that turns these cookies into something unexpectedly delightful.
- Cookies and cream: A perfect match that doubles the cookie flavor. Try using it with crushed Oreos for extra crunch.
- Butter pecan or caramel swirl: These offer rich, buttery flavor and bake into a nutty, warm profile that’s hard to resist.
If you’re feeling festive, grab seasonal pints like Blue Bell’s Christmas Cookie ice cream, which adds sprinkles, frosting swirls, and sugar cookie bits. Wondering where can I buy Blue Bell Christmas Cookie ice cream? It’s usually available in large grocery stores during the holidays—check the freezer section or visit Blue Bell’s official site.
And yes, every one of these flavors will work beautifully when baked into your next batch of ice cream cookies.
Looking for creative pairings? Check out chocolate cookies or serve your cookies alongside a slice of cookie dough cake for double dessert joy.
Mix-ins and Pairings That Pop
Mix-ins take your ice cream cookies from good to unforgettable. Chocolate chips are classic, but there’s a whole world of tasty add-ins that complement different ice cream bases.
| Ice Cream Flavor | Best Mix-Ins |
|---|---|
| Vanilla | Chocolate chips, walnuts, sprinkles |
| Mint Chip | Dark chocolate chunks, crushed Andes mints |
| Strawberry | White chocolate chips, freeze-dried strawberries |
| Cookies and Cream | Oreo chunks, mini marshmallows |
| Butter Pecan | Pecans, caramel bits |
To make your ice cream cookies even more special, try adding flavored extracts like almond or peppermint, depending on the base flavor. And if you’re feeling bold, serve them warm with a scoop of matching ice cream in between—basically turning your cookie into a full dessert event.or special occasions.
Storing and Serving Ice Cream Cookies the Right Way
How to Store and Freeze Ice Cream Cookies
Once you’ve baked a delicious batch of ice cream cookies, you’ll want to keep them fresh for as long as possible. Luckily, these cookies store beautifully. In fact, their extra moisture from the ice cream makes them stay soft longer than traditional cookies.
Here’s how to store them:
- Room Temperature: Keep ice cream cookies in an airtight container for up to 4 days. Place a small piece of bread in the container to help retain moisture without making them soggy.
- Freezer Storage: To freeze baked cookies, cool them completely, then place them in a single layer on a baking sheet to freeze solid. Once frozen, transfer them to a zip-top freezer bag. They’ll stay fresh for up to 3 months.
- Freezing Dough: You can also freeze raw dough balls. Just scoop, chill for 30 minutes, and then freeze. When you’re ready to bake, place them directly on the baking sheet and add 1–2 extra minutes to your baking time.
Chilled or frozen, these cookies stay as soft and flavorful as the day you made them. If you’re gifting them, wrap each cookie in wax paper or plastic wrap for a cute and practical presentation.
For long-lasting party prep, pair frozen cookies with a fun dessert centerpiece like a cookies and cream ice cream cake, and you’ll have a ready-to-serve hit.
Creative Ways to Serve Ice Cream Cookies
Sure, you can serve your ice cream cookies straight from the cooling rack. But with a few small touches, you can transform them into party-worthy treats.
Here are a few crowd-pleasing serving ideas:
- Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches: Grab two cookies, add a scoop of matching or contrasting ice cream in the center, and press gently. Roll the edges in sprinkles or mini chocolate chips for a bakery-style look. This also works beautifully with chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches.
- Dessert Boards: Arrange cookies with fruit, scoops of different ice creams, crushed candies, and syrups. A fun way to let guests build their own layered bites.
- Dipped Edges: Melt white or dark chocolate, dip half of each cookie, and decorate with chopped nuts, coconut, or crushed Oreos. Chill until the chocolate sets.
- Mini Ice Cream Cookie Stacks: Stack three small cookies with a spoonful of ice cream between each one. Drizzle with chocolate or caramel for a fancy twist.
For more cookie celebration ideas, check out cookie and cream cookies or get creative with cookie dough cake as a base.
And if you’ve ever wondered who invented cookies and cream ice cream, it’s a debate between South Dakota State University and Blue Bell Creameries. Both claim to have launched it in the late 1970s to early ’80s—but whoever started it, we’re just grateful it exists and that we can bake it into our cookies today.
Pro Tips to Perfect Your Ice Cream Cookies
Master These Techniques for Better Results
Baking ice cream cookies might seem like a quirky idea, but once you try it, you’ll see how much better your cookies can be with the right approach. These key techniques guarantee chewy centers, golden edges, and balanced flavor every single time:
- Use only full-fat ice cream
Skip low-fat or “light” varieties. Full-fat ice cream gives your cookies the rich, creamy fat content needed for a soft, satisfying bite. - Always chill the dough
Chill your dough for at least 30 minutes before baking. This prevents spreading and lets the dough rest, resulting in cookies with a beautifully chewy texture. - Scoop evenly, space correctly
A 2-tablespoon cookie scoop works best. Place cookies 2 inches apart. If chilled overnight, press each dough ball slightly so they bake flat and evenly. - Do not overmix
Once the flour goes in, mix until just combined. Overmixing activates too much gluten, which can make cookies tough. - Match flavors intentionally
Pair strawberry ice cream with white chocolate chips or butter pecan with chopped pecans and caramel. Let your ice cream inspire the whole cookie. - Double and freeze
Freeze unbaked dough or already-baked cookies. They reheat beautifully and are perfect for last-minute dessert cravings.
Add Flavor, Texture, and Fun
These extra tips are where the creativity really kicks in for your ice cream cookies:
- Flavor boosts: Add extracts like almond or peppermint to match your chosen ice cream. A drop of vanilla never hurts, even with vanilla-based ice cream.
- Layered cookie stacks: Bake smaller cookies, stack them with whipped cream or ice cream in between, and chill. Great for party platters!
- Dipped cookies: Dip half of each cookie in melted chocolate and coat with crushed Oreos, sprinkles, or chopped nuts for bakery-style presentation.
- Stuff it: Hide a surprise inside! A frozen truffle, ganache ball, or even a teaspoon of Nutella makes your ice cream cookies unforgettable.
- Upgrade your mix-ins: Think beyond basic chocolate chips. Try crushed pretzels, toffee bits, or peanut butter cups to elevate the texture.
If you’re already loving this twist, try pairing them with cookie and cream cookies or build a dessert board featuring your favorite cookie dough cake. These little touches will help you turn a fun recipe into a signature treat your guests will always remember.
Ice Cream Cookies
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- In a large bowl, cream together butter, brown sugar, and granulated sugar until light and fluffy.
- Add eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition. Mix in vanilla and softened ice cream.
- In a separate bowl, whisk together flour, baking soda, and salt. Gradually add to the wet mixture until just combined.
- Stir in chocolate chips or your favorite mix-ins like crushed cookies or nuts.
- Chill dough for 30 minutes to 1 hour to prevent spreading.
- Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C). Scoop dough onto parchment-lined baking sheets, spacing 2 inches apart.
- Bake for 10–12 minutes until edges are golden and centers are just set. Cool on baking sheet for 5 minutes, then transfer to wire rack.
Nutrition
Notes
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!Frequently Asked Questions About Ice Cream Cookies
What is Cookie Monster ice cream?
Cookie Monster ice cream is a bright blue, cookie-packed flavor that blends a creamy vanilla or cake batter base with chunks of Oreo cookies and chocolate chip cookie pieces. It’s fun, nostalgic, and perfect for kids—or anyone who grew up loving Sesame Street. When baked into ice cream cookies, it adds a bold color and a combo of crunchy and creamy textures that really stand out. You can even make your own Cookie Monster ice cream to fold directly into your dough.
Where can I buy Blue Bell Christmas Cookie ice cream?
Blue Bell Christmas Cookie ice cream is a seasonal flavor that typically shows up in major grocery stores across the U.S. starting in November. You can use Blue Bell’s official online store locator to find the nearest store that carries it. This festive ice cream is loaded with sugar cookie dough pieces, sprinkles, and icing swirls—making it ideal for holiday-themed ice cream cookies. They’re colorful, nostalgic, and loaded with flavor that screams celebration.
How to make cookies and cream ice cream?
Cookies and cream ice cream is incredibly easy to make. Start with a vanilla base—either homemade or softened store-bought—and mix in crushed Oreo cookies until fully blended. Once mixed, refreeze it until firm. You can use this creamy, cookie-studded blend as a batter ingredient for ice cream cookies or serve it on top of freshly baked ones for a full cookies-and-cream overload.
Who invented cookies and cream ice cream?
Both South Dakota State University and Blue Bell Creameries claim to have invented cookies and cream ice cream in the late 1970s or early 1980s. While the debate is still unresolved, the important part is how it revolutionized frozen desserts. Today, it’s one of the most popular flavors—and when added to ice cream cookies, it brings familiar, nostalgic comfort in every bite.
Conclusion: Why Ice Cream Cookies Deserve a Spot in Your Recipe Box
Ice cream cookies are more than a fun twist—they’re a celebration of creativity, comfort, and flavor. Whether you’re using up leftover scoops or baking for a party, these cookies deliver soft, chewy perfection with a flavor punch you can customize endlessly. From classic vanilla and cookies and cream to bold picks like mint chip or Cookie Monster, each batch can be uniquely yours.
Thanks to a few simple techniques—like chilling the dough, using full-fat ice cream, and pairing smart mix-ins—you’ll get bakery-worthy results every time. And don’t forget, this recipe freezes well, scales up for gifting, and never fails to impress. If you’ve made traditional cookies before, ice cream cookies will become your next favorite go-to treat.
Want to explore more cookie creativity? Try chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches, cookie and cream cookies, or a fun cookie dough cake for your next baking day.